ExpressVPN and Surfshark are the two of the best VPNs in the current market, but the high price of ExpressVPN drives a lot of people away as compared to Surfshark which has a much cheaper offer. Is ExpressVPN worth the price?
We tested two VPNs and reviewed real user discussions on Reddit to help you make an informed choice.
SurfShark vs ExpressVPN: Which one is worth purchasing?
1, Speed: Both are fast, but Surfshark is a bit faster.
To assess Surfshark vs ExpressVPN in terms of speeds, I put both providers’ fastest available protocols to the test, namely, Surfshark’s WireGuard and ExpressVPN’s Lightway. To perform the test, I used Speedtest by Ookla, and the baseline was 500 Mbp/s for both download and upload speeds.
Both VPNs are optimized for speed. They’ve taken measures to avoid congested servers, too. Surfshark caps its server load at 40% to prevent slowdowns, while ExpressVPN automatically connects you to the least-congested server.
The data in the table shows the average download and upload speeds from servers in the US, the UK, and Canada.
| Download Retention | Surfshark VPN | ExpressVPN |
 US (NY) | 96% (482 Mbit/s) | 91% (459 Mbit/s) |
 United Kingdom | 93% (467 Mbit/s) | 92% (461 Mbit/s) |
 Canada | 94% (473 Mbit/s) | 91% (456 Mbit/s) |
| Upload Retention | ||
| US (NY) | 79% (399 Mbit/s) | 92% (464 Mbit/s) |
| United Kingdom | 84% (424 Mbit/s) | 92% (461 Mbit/s) |
| Canada | 81% (405 Mbit/s) | 89% (448 Mbit/s) |
From our test data in the table, it is clear that Surfshark is a faster VPN service compared to ExpressVPN in terms of download speeds, offering 1-5% faster downloads. On the other hand, ExpressVPN was faster in terms of upload speeds. However, since download speeds are generally more important for users, I declare Surfshark the winner.
Given that both VPNs have a minimal impact on speed, you won’t have any issues with either one if speed is your priority.
Note: Speed test results may vary in relation to the distance between the VPN server and the user, internet service provider, and server overcrowding. When you look at the reviews on some websites or read about the discussions of users on Reddit, you will see people with varying opinions about the speed. Some would say Surfshark is faster, while others would express that ExpressVPN is faster. This is because of the different conditions that can affect the user experience.
So the best way is to test it yourself using the VPN software’s 30-day money-back guarantee policy.
Recommendation: Unless you are in search of the fastest VPN, then speed should not be the sole factor affecting your decision-making since ExpressVPN and Surfshark have very little impact on the native network speed, and the effect is so small that you wouldn’t even notice the difference.
Both ExpressVPN and Surfshark offer a 30-day money-back guarantee. It’s a no-questions-asked policy, which essentially becomes a VPN free trial. You can make the most of the refund policy to effectively use ExpressVPN for free and use Surfshark for Free.
I suggest starting with Surfshark first, as it offers excellent service and is very cost-effective. In comparison, ExpressVPN is indeed too expensive.
2, Privacy & Security – ExpressVPN raises concerns for some users.
When it comes to privacy and logs, SurfShark and ExpressVPN are great options. Both of these VPNs are verified as no logs VPNs.
However, ExpressVPN received criticism after being acquired by known malware distributor Kape Technologies in 2021. Kape previously made money through ad platforms. You can see a lot of criticism on Reddit with many people giving up using ExpressVPN because of this!
Even more concerning is that Kape seems to be experiencing operational issues. A few months ago, the company laid off a significant portion of its global workforce. Even ExpressVPN’s Chief Technology Officer for Privacy, Dan Gericke, announced his departure on LinkedIn.
It’s certainly possible that ExpressVPN (or other Kape-owned VPNs like CyberGhost and PIA) will suffer a noticeable blow to quality, especially with the engineering and QA departments have been hit heavily. However, all we can do for now is wait and see.
In summary, it is currently not recommended to purchase VPN from Kape. The reason is very simple, if there are more trustworthy options out there, why settle for one that may be risky?
Check Out Surfshark’s No-Logs Policy Here >>
3, While much cheaper, Surfshark’s customer satisfaction is comparable to that of ExpressVPN
Priced at nearly one-third of ExpressVPN’s cost, Surfshark offers product experience, service quality, and customer satisfaction on par with ExpressVPN. Both have the same score on TrustPilot, reaching as high as 4.4.
The Winner: Tie
Visit SurfShark to Discover all Features >>
4, Price – Equally excellent, why spend nearly three times as much money?
ExpressVPN and Surfshark are currently the top VPNs in the market and display great qualities. However, Surfshark offers significantly lower prices then ExpressVPN. We consider it to be one of the best cheap VPNs on the market, under $3 per month.
According to my testing, Surfshark offers better security and has its own advantages in terms of speed, unless Surfshark does not support the country you’re in or after the trial period you find that it does not perform well due to your location, otherwise there is no need to pay nearly 3 times the price for ExpressVPN.
If you are really still on the fence, keep in mind that ExpressVPN and Surfshark both offer a 30-day money-back guarantee. Therefore you could purchase both VPNs, test each service for a few weeks, and then cancel the one you don’t want for a full refund.
Get the current maximum discount on two VPNs through my link.
Try Surfshark Now – Get 85% Off + 2 Months FREE >> (Limited Time Offer)
Try ExpressVPN Now – Get 49% Off + 3 Months FREE >>
Today Only! 30 day money-back guarantee.
5, Both Surfshark and ExpressVPN cover the most in-demand countries.
| Surfshark | ExpressVPN | |
|---|---|---|
| Countries | 100 | 105 |
| Countries with City-Level Choice | 11 | 14 |
| Servers | 3,200 | 3,000 |
Surfshark and ExpressVPN both have more server locations than most of the competition. Surfshark offers 100, while ExpressVPN has roughly 105 at the time of writing. Both cover the most in-demand countries (such as the US and UK), so neither is really “best”. The only exception is if you specifically need an IP address from a country that only one of these VPNs supports.
- Check out the list of countries supported by Surfshark >>
- Check out the list of countries supported by ExpressVPN >>
6, Surfshark allows for Unlimited Simultaneous Connections
ExpressVPN allows for 8 simultaneous connections and offers a custom router for situations where 8 simultaneous connections are not enough. Surfshark takes a different approach. With Surfshark, you get unlimited simultaneous connections. You can have as many devices actively using the internet as you wish, all for the price of a single subscription.
Visit SurfShark to Discover all Features >>
7, Security & Technical – Surfshark is marginally more secure than ExpressVPN
The table below shows a comparison of Surfshark and ExpressVPN’s encryption and security features.
| Surfshark | ExpressVPN | |
|---|---|---|
| VPN Protocols | WireGuard & OpenVPN | Lightway & OpenVPN |
| Encryption Cipher | AES-256 & ChaCha20 | AES-256 & wolfSSL |
| Kill Switch | Yes | Yes |
| Leak Protection | Yes | Yes |
| First-Party DNS | Yes | Yes |
| Open-Source Apps | No | Browser Extension Only |
| Colocated Servers | Yes | No |
Both Surfshark and ExpressVPN use strong security protocols, including OpenVPN, IKEv2/IPSec. Unfortunately, Express does not have WireGuard like Surfshark does, they instead use their own Lightway protocol. We found that ExpressVPN’s macOS client will leak your true IP address when changing server locations.
Check Out Surfshark’s Security Features Here >>
Conclusion: Surfshark wins in 2024
We like and recommend both of these VPN services. Both of them stand head and shoulders above the vast majority of the VPNs on the market.
However, in the past few years, we have seen Surfshark VPN improve more rapidly than ExpressVPN.
Ultimately, either of these VPNs may be the right choice for your unique circumstances. Both offer a 30-day money-back guarantee, which means you can test each one risk-free and keep the service you like the best.
Whichever VPN you decide to go with, be sure to get the best savings with the discounts below:
Surfshark’s Cyber Deal is live:
Get 85% Off Surfshark plus an extra 2 months FREE below:
(Limited Time Offer)
(Coupon is applied automatically; 30 day money-back guarantee)
And now for ExpressVPN.
Right now, 49% off is the best deal you can get on ExpressVPN. Even with the discount, ExpressVPN is still much more expensive than Surfshark — about double the price.
If you are really still on the fence, keep in mind that ExpressVPN and Surfshark both offer a 30-day money-back guarantee. Therefore you could purchase both VPNs, test each service for a few weeks, and then cancel the one you don’t want for a full refund.
ExpressVPN Coupon
SAVE: 49% + 3 months free
(Coupon is applied automatically; 30 day money-back guarantee.)
Well Express is pretty easy to use, good customer support, easy to install on a variety of routers, even found a good router in Bangkok, about 10 percent faster than my previous VPN, Will work on Firestick
A little more expensive, more and more servers are blocked by the streaming services. This is a problem for Live TV with Hulu as it is Zip Code Specific, they have been able to provide a working server for Sling TV.
Not enough cons to make me look for something else
Surfshark is cheap and it works well, my only complaint is the desktop app on pc is terrible, loads of annoying things where they want you to upgrade, pop ups, opens on startup and never closes properly. Also it doesn’t support port forwarding but that’s minor
Most VPNs are pretty similar, so unless your looking for something very specific, find the cheapest deal on a good rated VPN.
I’ve been on EVPN for two months. Made the switch only for their advertised windows split-tunneling. While using split-tunneling on Windows several programs that have been filtered not to use the VPN won’t function. Support says their engineers are working on it with no time estimate. Whats worse is they release updates to their app without really saying what was changed just that incredibly stupid playful things that companies say when they don’t think their users care like “We adjusted a few gears for you to make sure things run smoothly!” It’s pretty annoying to say the least.
If they don’t fix the issues with split-tunneling soon I may as well go back to my previous VPN provider because apparently no one has decent split-tunneling for windows anyway.
I’m curious how Surfshark’s speeds compare to top performers like ExpressVPN and NordVPN. But still seems fast enough for most.
I am disappointed that ExVPN now has an AppleTV app and Surfshark does not.